Wednesday, January 4, 2006

What can bloggers accomplish?


Jane Hamsher, who has been diligently dogging the Plame case at the firedoglake blog, has some interesting thoughts on the niche political blogs fill.  Or at least fit into: Dirty Rotten Bloggers 01/01/06.  She writes (my emphasis):

I can only speak about my own experience, as someone who regularly converses with numerous journalists who cover the CIA leak case for the purpose of getting a better understanding of what's going on. And these are remarkably smart people, because I'm not going to waste my time talking to the dumb ones. But their job is to stay on the phone all day and cultivate sources, and their memories probably don't extend a whole lot further than the article they wrote yesterday.

They do not spend the hours and days sifting through raw data now available to average people on the internet. I cannot emphasize this strongly enough. That is not what they do. If you want to know some obscure detail about something Judith Miller did or said in June of 2003 you call emptywheel. If you need to know about journalists named in the subpoenas sent to the White House in January 2003 you email Jeralyn. If you expect that kind of depth of knowledge about details from the people whose job it is to dig up new dirt in this case, they don't have it. They don't have the time.

In this light bloggers serve the function of analysts. Or re-analyzers, more aptly, who attempt to contextualize as they sort through available data and look for patterns, inconsistencies and greater truths. For my money if I was trying to marry a blog with a newsroom that's where I'd start - I'm constantly amazed that with all the access to information now available the big news bureaus don't have a deeper pool of researchers to be the adjunct memories of people who spend their time in the development of external news sources.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

If they did, we would never have had the "Coal Miner's Fiasco" rich

Anonymous said...

One of many ways in which a genuinely alert press could make much more positive contributions to our society's well-being. - Bruce